Lughaidh wrote:
Quote:
Irish was the first language I heard.
how is it possible that Irish is the 1st language Manchán heard, and that his Irish is so awful?
I taught Irish during one year in a university, and by the end of the year, some of my students pronounced better than him... (and they had only 2 hours every week, if I remember well). Not to mention grammar.
I constantly meet people born and raised in the Gaeltacht , through Irish, in Irish speaking homes that have a standard of spoken Irish you would associate with someone who's only exposure to Irish was through the school system.
on other occasions people have remarked how fluent speakers Irish changes to school Irish upon entering secondary school.
Just because they lack the native blas it doesn't mean they haven't been exposed to and immersed in the language since their earliest days.