galaxyrocker wrote:
Is there a way to determine where the prepositions would be placed? I was looking around on Duolingo, and someone asked why "Tá fadhb aici le drugaí" is accepted but "Tá fadhb le drugaí aici" isn't. One commentor (who is known to not give a shit about native speakers, who, in how own words, need to basically "fuck off") said it was a matter of emphasis, but I'm not sure about this. Is there just a general rule on where to place prepositions in phrasal verbs?
This kind of tá + ag + le (have with) is different from "tá rud le déanamh ag duine" (something is to be done by some one) as in the previous posting
Both aren't comparable.
Cúmhaí wrote:
If I recall correctly, single pronouns always go last and preposition-pronoun combos go right before them (or last if they are absent). So "tá fadhb le drugaí aici" would be the only correct choice.
For example "Rinne mé an t-aistriúchán leis" but "Rinne mé leis é"
Yes, simple pronouns and prepositional pronouns usually go last. But this is just a tendency, not a strict rule.
There are idioms (phrasal verbs etc.) which tie their prepositions next to them.
"To have" is such an idiom, so "aici" comes first and the additional information "le drugaí" goes last.