I don't like "an áit cladhairí". Of course, as well as the other two versions we could use the preposition instead of the genitive.
MacBoo wrote:
Not sure if there's any specific Ulster way of saying this so wait on other opinions (áit do chladhairí perhaps??)
There'd be nothing specifically Ulsterish about that - 'twould be the norm, I suppose - but using the Ulster form
fá choinne of the preposition
faoi choinne would give it that Ulster
blasSo:
Ní áit fá choinne cladhairí miseMacBoo wrote:
mandahxo wrote:
This is the context of the quote:
I am earth. I am sun and skies.
I am a world that cannot be explored
in one day.
[i]Mise talamh. Mise grian is speireacha.
Mise domhan nach féidir a thaiscéaladh
in aon lá amháin.
I think there may be identification vs classification sentence problems here. I'd say the definite article is understood in 'earth, sun and skies' , which would make it an identification sentence in Irish grammar terms. It's okay to omit the srticle in English, but I don't think we can in Irish - unless poetic licence says we can?. Or do we regard 'talamh', 'grian is spéartha' (CO) as proper nouns? On the other hand, 'I am a world that cannot be explored...' is clearly a classification sentence, and so would have to be 'Domhan mise nach féidir a thaiscéaladh ...'