mimerim wrote:
I'm practicing my R tapping. Sometimes I get it right, sometimes I don't. If I think about it too much I can't do it. But I've been wondering--if I'm trying to speak and I happen to not tap the R, will what I'm saying sound like gibberish, or will it just sound like an American accent?
The latter. ‘Urban Irish’ (a generic term used for the Irish spoken by people not in/from the Gaeltacht areas) often ends up substituting an English r for the tapped one.
And even in Gaeltacht Irish (in the north, anyway), r is often closer to the English r than to a tapped one before certain consonants;
ort ‘on you’, for example, is commonly pronounced as [ʌɹt] rather than [ʌɾ(ə)t]. (In IPA, [ɹ] = English r; [ɾ] = tapped r)
Also, if you speak some variant of more or less generic American, you’re actually quite used to making the tapped r—you just don’t think of it as an r. It’s the sound that’s made by a t between consonants in American English, as in ‘ma
tter’, which is pronounced [ˈmæɾɚ]. If you try saying that (not overly clear, just as you’d say it when speaking quickly) a few times and notice the sound in the middle of the word, and then try to disassociate that sound from the fact that in your head you’re saying a t, that can help you to more regularly and reliably tap your r’s properly.
